Vote NO · state
3
PROVIDES PERMANENT FUNDING FOR SCHOOLS AND HEALTH CARE BY EXTENDING EXISTING TAX ON HIGH INCOMES. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.
What it does
Makes permanent existing voter-approved tax rates for individuals earning over $371,000 (adjusted annually for inflation). Allocates tax revenues to public education. Fiscal Impact: Maintains $5 billion to $15 billion of annual state income tax revenue by making a temporary tax increase on high-income earners permanent instead of letting it expire in 2031.
Why Thrive LA opposes 3
Proposition 3 would amend the California Constitution to make permanent the higher income tax rates on high earners that voters first approved in 2012 (Proposition 30) and extended in 2016 (Proposition 55). Those rates apply to individuals earning over roughly $371,000 a year, adjusted for inflation, and are scheduled to expire in 2031. When they expire, the top three brackets of 10.3%, 11.3%, and 12.3% would return to 9.3%. Proposition 3 cancels that scheduled reduction permanently. Revenue is directed 89% to K-12 schools and 11% to community colleges, with any excess potentially going to children's health care through Medi-Cal. Vote no. Supporters say Proposition 3 is not a new tax, and that is technically true. But voters approved these rates as temporary, twice. Both times, Californians were told the increase would end. Proposition 3 breaks that promise and writes California's highest-in-the-nation top income tax rates into the constitution with no end date. With the existing Mental Health Services surcharge, the top rate stays at 13.3%. Every state with no income tax gains a permanent recruiting advantage over California. The sunset was the accountability. A temporary tax forces Sacramento to come back to voters and prove the money is being spent well. Making it permanent removes that check for good. The state Legislative Analyst estimates the revenue at $5 billion to $15 billion a year, a $10 billion swing driven by the stock market. Locking that volatility into the budget guarantees boom-and-bust cycles, with spending that grows in good years and painful shortfalls when the market turns. This tax does not stay with the wealthy. High earners include the founders, investors, and business owners who decide whether to build, hire, and expand in California or somewhere else. Each one who leaves takes jobs, payroll, and investment capital with them, and that shrinks the tax base everyone else depends on. California's budget problem comes from spending without discipline. It does not come from a shortage of revenue. Before asking taxpayers for a permanent commitment, Sacramento should show it can spend what it already collects responsibly. Californians were promised a temporary tax, and Proposition 3 makes it permanent. Vote No on Proposition 3.
Key points
- A Temporary Tax, Made Permanent: Voters approved these rates in 2012 and 2016 as temporary measures set to expire. Proposition 3 cancels the scheduled 2031 reduction and writes the higher rates into the state constitution for good.
- Highest Rates in America: The measure locks in top marginal rates of up to 12.3%, or 13.3% with the mental health surcharge. That is the highest in the nation and a lasting disadvantage against states with no income tax.
- No More Voter Check: The sunset forced Sacramento to return to voters and justify the tax. Removing it eliminates the strongest accountability tool taxpayers have over this money.
- Built-In Budget Instability: Revenue swings between $5 billion and $15 billion a year depending on the stock market. Permanent reliance on that volatility guarantees boom-and-bust budgeting.
- Drives Away Job Creators: High earners include the entrepreneurs and investors who fund new businesses and housing. Making these rates permanent gives them one more reason to take their capital and jobs out of California.
See your full ballot
Get a personalized voter guide with every endorsed race + measure on your June 2 ballot.
Get your full voter guide